Introduction

 

Mortierella alpina, a fungus widely distributed in the soil, has a strong ability to produce lipids which account for up to 50% of its dry weight (Wang et al. 2013). At present, M. alpina is used commercially for the production of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs), especially arachidonic acid (Kikukawa et al. 2018). Besides, M. alpina produces many other polyunsaturated fatty acids, including linoleic acid, γ-linolenic acid, dihomo-γ-linolenic acid and eicosapentaenoic acid (Sakuradani 2010; Tang et al. 2018). These polyunsaturated fatty acids are very beneficial to human health,in that they are essential for normal physiological function (Wiktorowska-Owczarek et al. 2015; Madsen et al. 2019). Therefore, due to the oil-rich property and safety of M. alpina (Streekstra 1997; Nisha et al. 2009), it is considered a very promising producer of arachidonic acid, and it has attracted the attention of many researchers.

Although M. alpina has been used in the industrial production of arachidonic acid, optimization of fermentation conditions so as to increase yield is still the most direct and effective way for arachidonic acid production (Gu et al. 2018; Zhang et al. 2019). It has been proposed that when microorganisms are in a suitable environmental conditions with sufficient nutrition, various cellular metabolisms are active and in a state of balance. At this stage, cell metabolism mainly serves to promote cellular growth, while the lipid content in the cell is maintained at a low level. However, changes in environmental conditions impair the metabolic balance in the cell, a situation which is beneficial for the accumulation of some metabolites (Rattray 1984). Many factors affect the production of arachidonic acid through M. alpina fermentation. These factors include carbon source, nitrogen source, amount of dissolved oxygen, pH, and temperature. Nitrogen is a necessary nutrient element for the growth of microorganisms. Nitrogen source has significant effects on the growth of oleaginous microorganisms and the accumulation of lipids (Baky et al. 2020; Feng et al. 2020). Nitrogen limitation is a common strategy for inducing lipid synthesis in lipid-producing microorganisms (Janssen et al. 2019; Tossavainen et al. 2019). It has been shown that the yield of mono-unsaturated fatty acids in Saccharomyces cerevisiae was higher under nitrogen-limited conditions than that under non-nitrogen limited conditions (Tang and Chen 2014). Previous studies have revealed that oil-producing microorganisms begin to accumulate vast amounts of lipids only when the nitrogen source is exhausted and the carbon source is sufficient (Granger et al. 1993; Raimondi et al. 2014).

At present, research on the effect of nitrogen sources on lipid accumulation in M. alpina focus mainly on the selection of nitrogen sources and the optimization of fermentation conditions (Lu et al. 2011; Asadi et al. 2018; Lu et al. 2019). Studies have shown that the available nitrogen sources for M. alpina are inorganic and organic nitrogen sources, and the direction and yield of metabolites are influenced by different types of nitrogen sources (Stressler et al. 2013; Yu et al. 2018). A study on the effects of eight nitrogen sources on the characteristics of fatty acids in M. alpina showed that organic nitrogen sources were more favorable for cell growth and total lipid accumulation, than inorganic nitrogen sources, with urea being the most economical nitrogen source for industrial production of arachidonic acid (Lu et al. 2011). However, there are limited reports on the effect of nitrogen concentration on lipid accumulation in M. alpina. Moreover, different strains of M. alpinamay present distinct demands for nitrogen. In this study, the effects of six nitrogen sources (ammonium chloride, ammonium nitrate, ammonium sulfate, sodium nitrate, potassium nitrate, and urea) on the growth and fatty acid accumulation of M. alpine of M. alpina were investigated. Mortierella alpine D36 was fermented with sodium nitrate and urea as nitrogen sources under different nitrogen concentrations (0.05, 0.1 and 0.2 M). Dynamic changes in biomass concentration, nitrogen residue, fatty acid content, and yields of mycelia were measured during the fermentation. This could provide a reference for the industrial production of polyunsaturated fatty acids using M. alpina.

 

Materials and Methods

 

Fungal strain

 

Mortierella alpina D36 was previously isolated from the soil by the Laboratory of Food Microbiology, Yunnan Agricultural University, and identified using morphological and ITS sequences. This fungal strain was maintained on potato dextrose agar (PDA) slants at 4ºC.

 

Fermentation methods

 

The mycelia of M. alpina D36 were aseptically picked from the PDA slant medium and transferred to the inoculum medium comprised of glucose (30 g L-1), yeast extract (6 g L-1,) KH2PO4 (3 g L-1), NaNO3(3 g L-1) and MgSO4·7H2O (0.5 g L-1. The fungus was cultured with shaking at 175 rpm in Erlenmeyer flasks for 3 days at 20ºC. Then, 10–15 mycelium pellets were transferred to the fermentation medium containing glucose (50 g L-1), KH2PO4 (3.8 g L-1), MgSO4·7H2O (0.5 g L-1), and a specific nitrogen source (any of ammonium chloride, ammonium nitrate, ammonium sulfate, sodium nitrate, potassium nitrate, and urea). The amount of each nitrogen source was calculated based on 0.1 M nitrogen. Four replicates were carried out with each nitrogen source. The fungus was cultured in Erlenmeyer flasks for 12 days at 20ºC, with shaking at 175 rpm.

 

The formula of media

 

Different sodium nitrate concentrations were used to replace the nitrogen source in the above fermentation medium at concentrations of 4.25, 8.5 and 17 g L-1. Similarly, the nitrogen source in the fermentation medium was replaced with urea at concentrations of1.5, 3.0and 6.0 g L-1. The nitrogen concentrations in the medium were equivalent to 0.05 M, 0.1 M, and 0.2 M, respectively.

 

 

Fig. 1: Biomass concentration of M. alpina cultivated with different nitrogen sources. Data are expressed as mean ± SE of four replicates. Data with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

 

 

 

Fig. 2: Biomass concentration of M. alpina cultivated with different nitrogen concentrations during fermentation. (A) Sodium nitrate as nitrogen source; (B) urea as nitrogen source. Data are expressed as mean ± SE of four replicates. Data with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

 

Determination of biomass concentration in medium

 

The mycelia from each fermentation medium were harvested using vacuum filtration, and washed three times with distilled water, followed by freeze-drying to a constant weight. Biomass concentration was expressed in terms of dry cell weight (DCW) per liter of fermentation medium.

 

Determination of nitrogen residue in media

 

The nitrogen content of the medium was determined using alkaline potassium persulfate digestion in combination with ultraviolet spectrophotometry (Sattayatewa et al. 2011).

 

Analysis of fatty acids

 

Dry mycelia (50 mg) were added to 1 mL of toluene, 2 mL of 1% (v/v) sulphuric acid in methanol, and 1 mL of heptadecanoic acid (1 mgmL-1 in hexane). The mixture was placed in a 50°C-water bath overnight. Then, 5 mL of 5% (w/v) NaCl was added, followed by two extractions with hexane. The hexane layer was evaporated with N2, and the residue was dissolved in 1 mL of hexane for GC-MS analysis (Agilent 7890A/5975C). The GC-MS conditions and methods used were in line with those reported in a previous report (Gu et al. 2018). The quantity of each fatty acid component was calculated from the peak area on the chromatogram using C17: 0 as the internal standard.

 

Statistical analysis

 

Statistical analysis was performed with S.P.S.S. 19.0. Differences amongst multiple groups were determined using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), followed by Ducan’s multiple range test. Values of P ˂ 0.05 were taken as indicative of statistical significance.

Results

 

Effects of six nitrogen sources on biomass concentration of M. alpina

 

The nitrogen sources had significant effects on the biomass concentration of M. alpina (Fig. 1). The highest biomass concentration was 16.9 g L-1 when urea was used as the nitrogen source, followed by biomass concentration from use of ammonium nitrate (14.6 g L-1). However, when the other four nitrogenous compounds were used as nitrogen sources, the biomass concentrations were all below 5 g L-1, with sodium nitrate producing the lowest biomass concentration (2.6 g L-1). Therefore, urea was the best nitrogen source for M. alpina, while sodium nitrate was the worst nitrogen source.

 

Effect of nitrogen concentration on biomass of M. alpina

 

With sodium nitrate or urea as the nitrogen source, the biomass concentration of M. alpina was gradually increased time-dependently (Fig. 2). However, when sodium nitrate was used as the nitrogen source, there were no significant differences in fungal biomass under different nitrogen concentrations on the third day of fermentation. As the fermentation proceeded, M. alpina grew fastest under low sodium nitrate concentration (Fig. 2A). Furthermore, the highest biomass was 6.42 g L-1, which was significantly higher than those under medium and high sodium nitrate concentrations. There was no statistical difference in biomass concentration between the medium and high concentrations at each time point of the fermentation, except for the 12th day.

Using urea as nitrogen source, the biomass values under the medium concentration condition on the 3rd, 6th, and 9th days of fermentation were significantly higher than those under the low and high concentrations (Fig. 2B). However, on the 12th day of fermentation, biomass under high urea concentration condition surpassed that under medium concentration condition, and reached the highest value of 18.19 g L-1. Moreover, at the same fermentation time, the biomass resulting from use of organic nitrogen urea as the nitrogen source was significantly higher than that resulting from the use of inorganic nitrogen sodium nitrate as the nitrogen source (Fig. 2A, Fig. 2B). At the 12thday of fermentation, biomass concentration with urea as the nitrogen source was 2.83 times higher than that produced with sodium nitrate as nitrogen source. Therefore, urea was more suitable for the growth of M. alpina than sodium nitrate (Fig. 2).

 

Residual nitrogen in fermentation media during the growth of M. alpina

 

In this study, nitrogen consumption by M. alpina depended on type of nitrogen source and nitrogen concentration in the media (Fig. 3). When sodium nitrate was the nitrogen source, nitrogen was slowly consumed by M. alpina. At the end of the fermentation, the nitrogen in the media with three concentrations of sodium nitrate (0.05, 0.1 and 0.2 M) was not depleted (Fig. 3A). Nitrogen consumption in the media with the low concentration of sodium nitrate was 0.035 M, which was 2.33 times higher than nitrogen consumption at the high concentration of sodium nitrate.

When urea was used as the nitrogen source to cultivate M. alpina, nitrogen content in the media decreased sharply with time (Fig. 3B). At the low urea concentration of 0.05 M, nitrogen in the media was depleted on the 9th day. At the medium urea concentration of 0.1 M, the nitrogen consumption was 0.093 M at the end of fermentation, whereas, at a high nitrogen concentration of 0.2 M, the nitrogen consumption was 0.14 M at the end of the fermentation. Correlation analyses showed that, irrespective of whether sodium nitrate or urea was used as the nitrogen source, the biomass concentration of M. alpine was significantly positively correlated with nitrogen consumption (Pearson correlation coefficient r = 0.816, n = 48, P ≤ 0.001 for sodium nitrate; r = 0.903, n = 48, P ≤ 0.001 for urea).

 

Effect of nitrogen concentration on the proportion of fatty acids in M. alpina

 

M. alpina D36 was cultured with different concentrations of nitrate or urea for 12 days. The fatty acid profiles of M. alpina

N.  

 

Fig. 3: Residual nitrogen in the fermentation media during the growth of M. alpina. (A) Sodium nitrate as the nitrogen source; (B) urea as the nitrogen source. Data with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

cultured with different nitrogen concentrations are shown in Table 1. At different concentrations of the same nitrogen source, the fatty acid profiles did not differ much, except for the lack of lignoceric acid (C24:0) in the medium- and high-concentration sodium nitrate media. Monounsaturated fatty acid C24:1 was increased in mycelia when urea was used as the nitrogen source, when compared with sodium nitrate. Arachidonic acid was the most typical and the most abundant fatty acid in M. alpina.

With sodium nitrate as the nitrogen source, the level of arachidonic acid in total fatty acids fluctuated between 19.13 and 33.77%. At low sodium nitrate concentration, arachidonic acid level gradually decreased with fermentation time, but it was highest (27.54%) on the third day. Nevertheless, at the medium and high concentrations of sodium nitrate, the level of arachidonic acid first increased, and then decreased. Moreover, the arachidonic acid at the middle concentration of sodium nitrate reached a maximum level of 33.77% on the 6th day of fermentation. At the high concentration of sodium nitrate, the arachidonic acid level was only 19.55% on the 12th day of fermentation (Table 1).

With urea as nitrogen source, arachidonic acid level fluctuated between 22.02 and 34.32%. Unlike sodium nitrate, the levels of arachidonic acid at the low, medium, and high concentrations of urea slowly increased with fermentation time. Moreover, arachidonic acid level was higher at the low and medium concentrations of urea than at the high concentration of urea (Table 1).

The levels of saturated fatty acids, monounsaturated fatty acids and polyunsaturated fatty acids in total fatty acids are shown in Fig. 4 (A–C). In most cases, polyunsaturated fatty acids in M. alpina accounted for more than 50% of total fatty acids, and even exceeded 60% at low urea concentration. Overall, nitrogen source and nitrogen concentration had no significant effects on the proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids (Fig. 4C).

Effect of nitrogen concentration on the fatty acid contents in M. alpina

 

Fatty acids contents in mycelia M. alpina cultivated under different nitrogen concentrations for 12 days are shown in Table 2. In most cases, the total fatty acid content (Fig. 5A) and the content of each fatty acid component (Table 2) increased gradually with increase in fermentation time. When sodium nitrate was used as the nitrogen source, nitrogen concentration had little effect on the levels of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, arachidonic acid, and eicosapentaenoic acid. However, when urea was used as nitrogen source, the contents of fatty acids at the low and medium nitrogen concentrations were significantly higher than those at the high concentration (Fig. 5A–D). Moreover, the fatty acid contents were significantly higher when urea was used as nitrogen source than when sodium nitrate was used as nitrogen source. Therefore, urea was more suitable for fatty acid production by M. alpina than sodium nitrate.

 

Effect of nitrogen concentration on the fatty acid yields in M. alpina

 

 

 

Fig. 4: Proportion of fatty acids in total fatty acids of M. alpina D36 cultivated at different nitrogen concentrations during fermentation. (A) Proportion of saturated fatty acids in total fatty acids; (B) Proportion of monounsaturated fatty acids in total fatty acids; (C) Proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids in total fatty acids. Data with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

The effects of nitrogen source and nitrogen concentration on yields of fatty acids were significant (Fig. 6A–D). At the same nitrogen concentration, the yields of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, arachidonic acid, and eicosapentaenoic acid, increased gradually as the fermentation continued. Compared with sodium nitrate, the yield of fatty acids using urea as nitrogen source was significantly higher, mainly due to the much higher biomass concentration of M. alpina when urea was used as nitrogen source. With sodium nitrate as nitrogen source, the yield of fatty acids decreased with increasing nitrogen concentration, which was consistent with the trend in biomass concentration. The yield of arachidonic acid was 190.87 mg L-1 at low sodium nitrate concentration on the 12th day, which was 1.78 times higher than the corresponding yield at medium concentration, and 3.97 times higher than the yield at high concentration.

With urea as the nitrogen source, the yield of fatty acids was highest at the medium nitrogen concentration. On the 12th day, the yields of polyunsaturated fatty acids and arachidonic acid at the medium urea concentration were 1866.66 and 1090.97 mg L-1, respectively, which were 1.53 and 1.66 times higher than the corresponding yields at low urea concentration, respectively. Moreover, the low and medium urea concentrations were conducive for the accumulation of eicosapentaenoic, another essential polyunsaturated fatty acid (Fig. 6D).

 

Discussion

 

Table 1: Levels of fatty acids of M. alpina D36 grown under different nitrogen concentrations during fermentation

 

Nitrogen source

Nitrogen concentration

Fermentation time (days)

Saturated fatty acids (%)

Monounsaturated fatty acids (%)

Polyunsaturated fatty acids (%)

 

 

C14:0

C16:0

C18:0

C22:0

C24:0

C18:1

C20:1

C24:1

LA (C18:2)

C20:2

GLA (C18:3)

DGLA (C20:3)

ARA (C20:4)

EPA (C20:5)

Sodium nitrate

Low

3

1.09±

0.05bcd

15.83±

0.37bc

8.74±

0.25de

0.81±

0.27d

0.63±

0.12c

18.28±

0.31bcd

0.63±

0.21ab

-

5.65±

0.08b

0.80±

0.33c

6.98±

0.16b

8.66±

0.03bc

27.54±

0.52bc

4.37±

0.22bc

6

1.00±

0.08cde

16.24±

0.19bc

10.07±

0.14cde

1.33±

0.05bc

0.75±

0.07b

15.52±

0.22cde

0.75±

0.04ab

-

4.95±

0.10cd

1.14±

0.06bc

5.79±

0.23bcd

8.28±

0.26bc

26.96±

0.48bc

7.23±

0.65a

9

0.93±

0.05de

16.82±

0.73abc

10.79±

0.25cd

1.51±

0.05bc

0.79±

0.04b

17.04±

0.83cde

0.73±

0.13ab

-

4.35±

0.09efg

1.09±

0.12bc

5.13±

0.12cdef

7.95±

0.54c

26.03±

1.57bcd

6.84±

0.39a

12

1.04±

0.02bcde

16.90±

0.60abc

10.69±

0.26bcd

1.45±

0.04bc

0.98±

0.06a

18.24±

1.03bcd

0.58±

0.05b

-

4.36

±0.22efg

0.92±

0.06c

5.52±

0.37cde

8.38±

0.45bc

23.75±

1.82cde

7.19±

0.62a

Medium

3

0.97±

0.05cde

17.60±

1.23abc

10.41±

0.75bcd

1.42±

0.11bc

-

15.72±

0.72cde

0.53±

0.02b

-

5.50±

0.19bc

1.15±

0.28bc

4.42±

0.28def

9.78±

0.51abc

29.40±

1.26b

3.20±

0.69c

6

0.80±

0.07e

16.18±

1.00bc

10.05±

0.82cde

1.50±

0.12bc

-

12.39±

0.75f

0.71±

0.07ab

-

4.44±

0.14def

1.25±

0.11abc

4.45±

0.19def

9.92±

0.38ab

33.77±

1.72a

4.52±

0.53bc

9

1.06±

0.07bcd

18.71±

1.24ab

12.19±

0.84ab

2.11±

0.19a

-

14.81±

0.86ef

0.82±

0.05ab

-

3.90±

0.22fgh

1.40±

0.15abc

4.15±

0.44ef

8.80±

0.89bc

27.80±

1.86bc

4.25±

1.26bc

12

1.18±

0.07bc

19.48±

1.01a

12.19±

1.07ab

2.19±

0.11a

-

18.69±

1.07bc

0.94±

0.06a

-

3.69±

0.13h

1.80±

0.23a

4.04±

0.39f

8.77±

0.62bc

21.72±

1.74def

5.28±

0.63abc

High

3

1.93±

0.08a

18.89±

0.60ab

8.32±

0.46e

0.32±

0.07e

-

25.49±

0.50a

0.09±

0.01c

-

6.80±

0.28a

0.13±

0.02d

9.46±

1.18a

6.14±

0.48d

19.13±

0.24f

3.30±

0.92c

6

1.16±

0.01bcd

16.31±

0.61bc

9.54±

0.62cde

1.04±

0.14cd

-

17.99±

1.07bcde

0.71±

0.18ab

-

5.86±

0373b

1.39±

0.29abc

6.41±

0.46bc

9.00±

0.55bc

25.37±

1.21bcd

5.24±

0.63abc

9

1.21±

0.11bc

15.32±

0.94c

11.59±

0.83ab

1.45±

0.16bc

-

14.61±

0.91def

0.79±

0.13ab

-

4.96±

0.10de

1.29±

0.05abc

4.47±

0.03def

11.39±

0.45a

25.98±

2.08bcd

7.09±

0.26a

12

1.26±

0.09b

18.42±

1.04abc

13.11±

0.41a

1.76±

0.13ab

-

21.00±

2.63b

0.71±

0.04ab

-

3.86±

0.16gh

1.54±

0.18abc

3.95±

0.73f

9.12±

1.04bc

19.55±

2.28ef

5.72±

0.50ab

Urea

Low

3

1.58±

0.09b

15.24±

0.21a

8.38±

0.25b

1.11±

0.04f

1.89±

0.19e

17.56±

0.22a

0.40±

0.05e

1.46±

0.02a

5.31±

0.36ab

0.55±

0.05e

7.85±

0.24b

8.77±

0.24bc

22.02±

0.52c

7.88±

0.68c

6

0.92±

0.03c

12.35±

0.17cd

8.04±

0.11bc

1.30±

0.03de

2.58±

0.11d

15.24±

0.27c

0.66±

0.22a

1.64±

0.32a

6.38±

0.91a

0.87±

0.14d

6.31±

0.13cd

9.60±

0.14a

27.74±

0.36b

9.66±

0.40b

9

0.66±

0.01e

11.64±

0.21d

6.37±

0.17fg

1.35±

0.01cd

3.37±

0.07c

12.10±

0.64e

0.49±

0.01bcd

1.46±

0.03a

3.11±

0.03d

1.27±

0.04bc

4.78±

0.07g

8.87±

0.10bc

32.55±

1.13a

11.98±

0.31a

12

0.49±

0.02f

13.66±

0.14b

6.16±

0.16gh

1.45±

0.04c

4.04±

0.13b

12.25±

0.33de

0.49±

0.01bcd

1.34±

0.06abc

3.56±

0.13cd

1.38±

0.08bc

4.27±

0.03h

7.82±

0.17d

32.46±

0.96a

10.64±

0.39ab

Medium

3

1.55±

0.07b

16.19±

0.20a

9.21±

0.19a

1.26±

0.06de

1.99±

0.11e

20.39±

0.56a

0.56±

0.01a

0.84±

0.08e

5.00±

0.19b

1.00±

0.07d

8.18±

0.23ab

9.09±

0.13bc

20.83±

1.40c

3.90±

0.42ef

6

0.88±

0.04c

13.60±

0.38b

7.77±

0.16cd

1.58±

0.01b

4.03±

0.16b

15.92±

0.58bc

0.58±

0.01a

0.73±

0.06e

3.90±

0.08c

1.22±

0.03c

5.94±

0.13de

9.22±

0.03ab

31.17±

0.89ab

3.84±

0.36f

9

0.83±

0.02cd

12.95±

0.40bc

6.94±

0.03e

1.61±

0.03b

4.44±

0.14ab

14.29±

0.31cde

0.54±

0.02abc

0.89±

0.05e

3.72±

0.07c

1.33±

0.10bc

5.34±

0.06f

8.87±

0.08bc

32.75±

1.12a

5.53±

0.44de

12

0.69±

0.06de

13.40±

0.37b

5.85±

0.13h

1.41±

0.02c

3.40±

0.77c

14.42±

0.20cd

0.47±

0.01cde

1.20±

0.07de

3.52±

0.14de

1.45±

0.06ab

4.65±

0.10gh

7.89±

0.03d

34.32±

0.52a

6.51±

0.84cd

High

3

1.72±

0.06a

15.83±

0.28a

8.52±

0.22b

1.21±

0.02ef

1.73±

0.06e

19.84±

0.58a

0.40±

0.03e

1.41±

0.06ab

5.52±

0.10a

0.61±

0.13e

8.46±

0.26a

7.77±

0.33d

20.67±

0.68c

6.29±

0.90cd

6

0.93±

0.06c

12.62±

0.25bcd

8.33±

0.09b

1.42±

0.04c

2.59±

0.12d

17.55±

0.70b

0.56±

0.03ab

1.23±

0.03bcd

3.64±

0.11d

1.23±

0.07bc

6.56±

0.16c

9.70±

0.15a

28.37±

0.97b

5.26±

0.76def

 

0.92±

0.04c

12.67±

0.29bcd

7.44±

0.12d

1.59±

0.03b

3.51±

0.06c

20.41±

0.56a

0.57±

0.02a

1.11±

0.04d

3.56±

0.05cd

1.58±

0.02a

5.74±

0.07ef

8.86±

0.12bc

28.40±

0.83b

3.47±

0.28f

12

0.65±

0.02e

11.83±

0.65d

6.71±

0.24ef

1.72±

0.07a

4.82±

0.23a

20.22±

2.02a

0.61±

0.01a

0.82±

0.10e

3.97±

0.15c

1.65±

0.02a

6.00±

0.25de

8.57±

0.19c

28.33±

2.49b

4.10±

0.73ef

“-” Indicates ‘not detected’. Data are expressed as mean ± SE of four replicates. Values with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

Nitrogen sources are essential for microbial growth, but not all nitrogen sources are suitable for the growth and oil accumulation of M. alpina. This study compared the effects of six nitrogen sources on the growth of M. alpina D36, and found that the organic nitrogen urea was the most beneficial for the growth of mycelia, followed by an inorganic nitrogen i.e. ammonium nitrate, while the most unfavorable nitrogen source was sodium nitrate. Moreover, urea was more conducive to accumulation of fatty acids in M. alpina than sodium nitrate. These results are consistent with the findings of other researchers who reported that organic nitrogen sources were more conducive for M. alpina growth and oil accumulation than inorganic nitrogen sources (Lu et al. 2011; Nisha and Venkateswaran 2011). Singh and Ward (1997) used 1% (w/v) corn steep instead of sodium nitrate, for cultivation of M. alpine, and found that the production of arachidonic acid improved significantly. Similar results were found in other organisms. Certik et al. (1999) compared lipogenesis and activities of lipogenic enzymes in the fungus Cunninghamella echinulata as a function of different inorganic and organic nitrogen sources, and found that organic nitrogen enhanced lipid accumulation. A study on the effects of sodium nitrite, sodium nitrate, urea, and ammonium chloride on the growth and lipid accumulation of marine algae Desmodesmus spp. WC08 showed that the use of urea produced the best growth and lipid accumulation of Desmodesmus spp. WC08 (Luo et al. 2016).

Table 2: Contents of fatty acids in M. alpina D36 grown at different nitrogen concentrations during fermentation

 

Nitrogen source

Nitrogen concentration

Fermentation time

Saturated fatty acids (mg g-1)

Monounsaturated fatty acids (mg g-1)

Polyunsaturated fatty acids (mg g-1)

C14:0

C16:0

C18:0

C22:0

C24:0

C18:1

C20:1

C24:1

LA (C18:2)

C20:2

GLA (C18:3)

DGLA (C20:3)

ARA (C20:4)

EPA (C20:5)

Sodium nitrate

Low

3

0.81±

0.04c

12.05±

0.79cd

6.54±

0.44d

0.61±

0.21c

0.26±

0.02c

13.17±

0.99bc

0.47±

0.16def

-

4.23±

0.31b

0.62±

0.29e

5.24±

0.42bcd

6.51±

0.53c

20.78±

2.04bc

3.31±

0.38efg

6

1.11±

0.07bc

18.20±

0.25abcd

11.29±

0.18abc

1.49±

0.06b

0.85±

0.09b

17.39±

0.28abc

0.84±

0.06bc

-

5.55±

0.05a

1.27±

0.06bc

6.50±

0.33bc

9.27±

0.27abc

30.21±

0.43ab

8.12±

0.80ab

9

1.10±

0.14bc

19.56±

1.33abcd

12.65±

1.15abc

1.77±

0.15b

0.92±

0.07b

19.78±

1.24abc

0.82±

0.05bcd

-

5.15±

0.58ab

1.31±

0.22bc

6.06±

0.68bcd

9.55±

1.47abc

31.23±

4.83ab

8.01±

0.86ab

12

1.32±

0.10abc

21.47±

1.50abc

13.61±

1.01ab

1.83±

0.07b

1.25±

0.07a

23.30±

2.48ab

0.73±

0.06bcde

-

5.50±

0.18a

1.17±

0.09bcd

7.00±

0.37ab

10.65±

0.80ab

30.30±

2.46ab

9.18±

1.08a

Medium

3

0.58±

0.03c

10.34±

0.70d

6.11±

0.41d

0.83±

0.08c

-

9.77±

0.71c

0.33±

0.01f

-

3.52±

0.37b

0.78±

0.14de

2.95±

0.36d

6.52±

0.64c

19.09±

2.08bc

2.46±

0.36g

6

1.04±

0.10bc

20.44±

1.60abc

12.73±

1.36abc

1.70±

0.07b

-

15.58±

1.25bc

0.85±

0.12bc

-

5.56±

0.13a

1.40±

0.05bc

5.31±

0.23bcd

11.75±

0.30a

41.08±

2.82a

5.06±

0.62cdef

9

1.36±

0.04abc

24.40±

1.24ab

15.75±

0.74a

2.73±

0.22a

-

19.17±

0.92abc

1.06±

0.09a

-

5.06±

0.33ab

1.83±

0.19b

5.41±

0.63bcd

11.49±

1.35a

36.30±

3.52a

5.61±

1.69bcde

12

1.63±

0.04a

27.02±

1.70a

14.24±

1.83ab

3.03±

0.11a

-

26.16±

2.47a

1.30±

0.07a

-

5.17±

0.48ab

2.54±

0.39a

5.75±

0.93bcd

12.39±

1.67a

30.42±

3.66ab

7.51±

1.35abc

High

3

1.33±

0.10abc

12.64±

1.07cd

5.88±

0.81d

0.43±

0.05c

-

17.43±

1.82abc

0.45±

0.10def

-

4.01±

0.55b

0.91±

0.22cde

7.18±

1.07a

4.52±

1.07c

13.76±

1.39c

2.86±

0.29g

6

1.14±

0.04bc

16.03±

0.46bcd

9.38±

0.49bcd

1.02±

0.11bc

-

17.69±

0.91abc

0.69±

0.13cde

-

5.77±

0.31a

1.35±

0.21bc

6.34±

0.56bc

8.86±

0.57abc

25.09± 1.81bc

5.20±

0.71cdef

9

1.38±

0.27abc

17.61±

1.61bcd

13.69±

1.60ab

1.72±

0.23b

-

17.18±

1.85abc

0.92±

0.12bc

-

5.39±

0.23ab

1.49±

0.16bc

5.18±

0.49bcd

12.29±

0.93a

27.62±

2.51bc

7.34±

0.38abcd

12

1.14±

0.09bc

16.63±

1.29bcd

11.91±

1.05abc

1.58±

0.12b

-

18.69±

1.36abc

0.66±

0.09cde

-

3.55±

0.43b

1.40±

0.20bc

3.71±

0.80d

8.52±

1.48abc

18.29±

3.39c

5.20±

0.59cdef

Urea

Low

3

1.21±

0.07cd

11.86±

1.18de

6.53±

0.69f

0.87±

0.12g

1.51±

0.32de

13.62±

1.22gh

0.31±

0.05cd

1.14±

0.13def

4.08±

0.28bcd

0.43±

0.28e

6.06±

0.45fg

6.84±

0.24e

17.12±

1.75f

6.24±

1.15de

6

1.12±

0.04cde

15.08±

0.64cd

9.82±

0.40de

1.60±

0.10ef

3.17± 0.24d

16.41±

2.35fg

0.84±

0.32ab

1.61±

0.50cd

7.75±

0.49a

1.05±

0.15cd

7.69±

0.21cde

11.72±

0.45cd

33.92±

1.76de

11.87±

1.01bc

9

1.21±

0.03cd

21.54±

1.16b

11.77±

0.63ab

2.48±

0.10bc

6.22±

0.21bc

22.36±

1.56cde

0.90±

0.04a

2.71±

0.15a

5.75±

0.28abcd

2.35±

0.14b

8.82±

0.31abc

16.36±

0.10a

60.01±

2.51b

22.19±

1.41a

12

1.04±

0.03efg

29.06±

1.28a

13.10±

0.69a

3.08±

0.17a

8.57±

0.39a

26.05±

1.28bc

1.04±

0.07a

2.84±

0.08a

7.06±

0.51ab

2.91±

0.10a

9.10±

0.42ab

16.64±

0.77a

69.15±

4.10a

22.66±

1.42a

Medium

3

0.93±

0.02fgh

9.82±

0.48ef

5.59±

0.29fg

0.77±

0.07g

1.21±

0.10e

12.39±

0.83gh

0.34±

0.02cd

0.51±

0.05g

3.02±

0.12cd

0.61±

0.07de

4.95±

0.17gh

5.52±

0.29ef

12.66±

1.15f

2.36±

0.27f

6

1.10±

0.05def

17.03±

0.52c

9.73±

0.30de

1.98±

0.09de

5.08±

0.39c

19.92±

0.60def

0.71±

0.02ab

0.92±

0.09efg

4.88±

0.16abcd

1.53±

0.09c

7.44±

0.20de

11.57±

0.51cd

39.22±

2.49cd

4.38±

0.53ef

9

1.44±

0.10a

22.52±

2.07b

12.01±

0.83ab

2.78±

0.21ab

7.69±

0.55ab

24.80±

2.06bcd

0.93±

0.10a

1.53±

0.12cd

6.45±

0.52abc

2.33±

0.34b

9.25±

0.69a

15.36±

1.05ab

56.29±

1.71b

9.65±

1.21cd

12

1.42±

0.04ab

28.11±

2.65a

12.17±

0.72ab

2.95±

0.20a

7.08±

1.65ab

30.13±

2.33ab

0.98±

0.09a

2.49±

0.19ab

7.30±

0.36ab

3.03±

0.31a

9.68±

0.58a

16.49±

1.25a

71.52±

4.84a

13.89±

2.51b

High

3

0.86±

0.04h

7.97±

0.53f

4.27±

0.22g

0.61±

0.05g

0.88±

0.08e

9.93±

0.40h

0.20±

0.03d

0.72±

0.07fg

2.77±

0.13d

0.32±

0.08e

4.23±

0.18g

3.93±

0.37f

10.43±

0.88f

3.22±

0.60ef

6

0.92±

0.04gh

12.58±

0.65de

8.32±

0.53e

1.43±

0.13f

2.61±

0.28de

17.40±

0.42efg

0.55±

0.02bc

1.26±

0.06def

3.63±

0.22cd

1.22±

0.05c

6.55±

0.45ef

9.71±

0.72d

28.46±

2.54e

5.30±

0.99ef

9

1.27±

0.05bc

17.49±

0.56c

10.28±

0.37cd

2.20±

0.10cd

4.85±

0.18c

28.22±

1.35ab

0.79±

0.04ab

1.53±

0.04cd

4.92±

0.12abcd

2.18±

0.08b

7.94±

0.31bcd

12.24±

0.36c

39.15±

0.68cd

4.81±

0.51ef

12

1.04±

0.06efg

18.95±

1.43bc

10.74±

0.61abc

2.75±

0.18ab

7.70±

0.41ab

32.45±

3.70a

0.97±

0.05a

1.31±

0.14de

6.35±

0.31abc

2.64±

0.13ab

9.61±

0.62a

13.74±

0.81bc

45.17±

3.67c

6.49±

1.04de

“-” Indicates ‘not detected’. Data are expressed as mean ± SE of four replicates. Values with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

In the present study, nitrogen concentration had little effect on the proportions of fatty acids in M. alpina. However, it significantly affected the contents and yields of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, arachidonic acid, and eicosapentaenoic acid. When urea was used as nitrogen source, the contents and yields of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and arachidonic acid at the low and medium nitrogen concentrations were higher than those at the high nitrogen concentration. These findings are consistent with the results obtained in a previous study in which the effects of low and high nitrogen concentrations on the growth and lipid accumulation of two oleaginous micro algae were investigated (Wu et al. 2015). The results showed that the levels of total lipids, neutral lipids, and total fatty acids produced by these two microalgae at low nitrogen concentration were significantly higher than those produced at the high nitrogen concentration. In the present study, using sodium nitrate as the sole nitrogen source, fungal biomass and total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and arachidonic acid yields decreased with increasing nitrogen concentration, indicating that a high concentration of nitrate could inhibit the growth and fatty acid accumulation of M. alpina. Using urea as nitrogen source, the nitrogen was completely consumed or nearly consumed at the low and medium nitrogen concentrations on the 9th and 12th days, at which time the mycelia of M. alpina grew slowly. However, the fungal biomass increased rapidly at the high nitrogen concentration on the 9th and 12th days, due to sufficient nitrogen content in the media. In other words, the low and medium urea concentrations were not conducive for the growth of M. alpina at the later stages of fermentation. It is likely that under nitrogen-restricted conditions, M. alpina initiated a stress-resistant physiological response which resulted in inhibition of mycelial protein synthesis, thereby decreasing the levels of enzymes required for mycelial growth and metabolism.

 

 

Fig. 5: Fatty acid contents of cell dry weight (mg g-1) in M. alpina D36 cultivated with different nitrogen concentrations during fermentation. (A) Total fatty acid contents of cell dry weight; (B) polyunsaturated fatty acid contents of cell dry weight; (C) arachidonic acid contents of cell dry weight; (D) eicosapentaenoic acid contents of cell dry weight. Data with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

 

 

 

Fig. 6: Fatty acid yields at different nitrogen concentrations during fermentation. (A) Total fatty acid yield; (B) polyunsaturated fatty acid yield; (C) arachidonic acid yield; (D) eicosapentaenoic acid yield. Data with different letters differ significantly (P < 0.05)

It is noteworthy that the biomass of M. alpine reached its maximum on the 12th day of fermentation at the high urea concentration, but the contents of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and arachidonic acid were significantly lower than the corresponding contents at the low and medium urea concentrations. These results are consistent with the findings in some studies which showed that oleaginous yeasts and molds accumulated high levels of lipids in nitrogen-restricted media (Arous et al. 2016; Janssen et al. 2019; Tossavainen et al. 2019). The primary function of a nitrogen source is to enhance the synthesis of proteins and nucleic acids. When the nitrogen source is limited, the synthesis of intracellular proteins and nucleic acids is blocked, and the tricarboxylic acid cycle is impeded, thereby suppressing cell proliferation and causing changes in metabolic pathways. Thus, the carbon flow in the media is channeled in the direction of lipid synthesis. A previous study showed that when a bioengineered strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae was cultivated under nitrogen-limited conditions, the yields of monounsaturated fatty acids were higher than the corresponding yields under sufficient nitrogen conditions (Tang and Chen 2014). Moreover, citrate level in the S. cerevisiae under limited nitrogen condition was much higher than that under ample nitrogen limited condition. The accumulated citrate in cells is cleaved by ATP-citrate lyase (ACL) to acetyl-CoA, thereby providing a key substrate for fatty acid synthesis.

The oil-producing performance of M. alpinais closely related not only to the fatty acid content of the fungal mycelia, but also to the biomass concentration. Low biomass reduces the yield of fatty acids. Therefore, this study also used the volumetric productivity of each fatty acid component to evaluate the fatty acid production performance of M. alpina. The results showed that with sodium nitrate as the nitrogen source, there was little change in the fatty acid content of M. alpina, but its biomass concentration was significantly lower, when compared with biomass with urea as the nitrogen source. As a result, the volumetric productivities of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and arachidonic acid were very low when sodium nitrate was used as the nitrogen source. Therefore, urea is more suitable for the growth and accumulation of fatty acids in M. alpina than sodium nitrate. In this study, with urea as nitrogen source, low nitrogen concentration (0.05 M) was beneficial to the accumulation of fatty acids, but it was not conducive for the growth of M. alpina. Sufficient nitrogen at high concentration (0.2 M) promoted the growth of M. alpina, but inhibited the accumulation of fatty acids in mycelia. However, biomass concentration and fatty acid production of M. alpina were higher under medium concentration of urea (0.1 M). Generally, the inverse relationship between biomass concentration and lipid accumulation is the most significant technical bottleneck faced when using M. alpina to produce lipids. If the nitrogen demand can be accurately controlled, the biomass concentration and lipid content of M. alpina can be increased, so that the yields of polyunsaturated fatty acids, especially arachidonic acid, can be maximized.

 

Conclusion

 

The effects of nitrogen sources and nitrogen concentrations on the mycelial growth and fatty acid accumulation of M. alpina were determined in this study. The results suggest that the biomass concentration, and contents and yields of total fatty acids, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and arachidonic acid are regulated when M. alpine is grown under different nitrogen sources and concentrations. In this study, urea was more beneficial to the growth and fatty acid accumulation of M. alpine than sodium nitrate, and the biomass and fatty acid yields at the medium urea concentration were relatively high. However, the mechanism underlying the effect of nitrogen source and its concentration on the growth and fatty acid synthesis of M. alpine is unclear. This needs further research.

Acknowledgements

 

This work was supported by the Key Project of Yunnan Provincial Agricultural Union (2017FG001-015), and the Natural Science Fund of Yunnan province (2016FB030).

 

Author Contributions

 

Lingfei Li designed the study and revised the manuscript. Lingfei Li and Na Jin performed the experiments and analyzed the data. Lingfei Li wrote the first draft of the manuscript.

 

References

 

Arous F, T Mechichi, M Nasri, G Aggelis (2016). Fatty acid biosynthesis during the life cycle of Debaryomyces etchellsii. Microbiology 162:1080–1090

Asadi SZ, K Khosravi-Darani, H Nikoopour, H Bakhoda (2018). Production of arachidonic acid and eicosapentaenoic acid by Mortierella alpina CBS 528.72 on date waste. Food Technol Biotechnol 56:197–207

Baky HHAE, GSE Baroty, EM Mostafa, M Enas (2020). Optimization growth of Spirulina (Arthrospira) platensis in photobioreactor under varied nitrogen concentration for maximized biomass, carotenoids and lipid contents. Rec Pat Food Nutr Agric 11:40–48

Certik M, J Megova, R Horenitzky (1999). Effect of nitrogen sources on the activities of lipogenic enzymes in oleaginous fungus Cunninghamella echinulata. J Gen Appl Microbiol 45:289–293

Feng P, Z Xu, L Qin, MA Alam, Z Wang, S Zhu (2020). Effects of different nitrogen sources and light paths of flat plate photobioreactors on the growth and lipid accumulation of Chlorella spp. GN1 outdoors. Bioresour Technol 301:122762

Granger LM, P Perlot, G Goma, A Pareilleux (1993). Efficiency of fatty acid synthesis by oleaginous yeasts: Prediction of yield and fatty acid cell content from consumed C/N ratio by a simple method. Biotechnol Bioeng 42:1151–1156

Gu X, X Fu, L Li (2018). Effect of temperature and agitation speed on fatty acid accumulation in Mortierella alpina. Intl J Agric Biol 20:2319–2324

Janssen JH, RH Wijffels, MJ Barbosa (2019). Lipid production in Nannochloropsis gaditana during nitrogen starvation. Biology 8; Article 5

Kikukawa H, E Sakuradani, A Ando, S Shimizu, J Ogawa (2018). Arachidonic acid production by the oleaginous fungus Mortierella alpina 1S-4: A review. J Adv Res 11:15–22

Lu H, H Chen, X Tang, Q Yang, H Zhang, YQ Chen, W Chen (2019). Ultra performance liquid chromatography-Q exactive orbitrap/mass spectrometry-based lipidomics reveals the influence of nitrogen sources on lipid biosynthesis of Mortierella alpina. J Agric Food Chem 67:10984–10993

Lu J, C Peng, XJ Ji, J You, L Cong, P Ouyang, H Huang (2011). Fermentation characteristics of Mortierella alpina in response to different nitrogen sources. Appl Biochem Biotechnol 164:979–990

Luo N, S Zhang, P Liu (2016). Effects of nitrogen and phosphorus on cell growth and lipid accumulation of tropic ocean microalgae strain Desmodesmus spp. WC08. Sci Technol Food Indus 37:223–227

Madsen MTB, AA Bjerregaard, JD Furtado, TI Halldorsson, M Ström, C Granström, E Giovannucci, SF Olsen (2019). Comparisons of estimated intakes and plasma concentrations of selected fatty acids in pregnancy. Nutrients 11; Article 568

Nisha A, G Venkateswaran (2011). Effect of culture variables on mycelial arachidonic acid production by Mortierella alpina. Food Bioproc Technol 4:232–240

Nisha A, SP Muthukumar, G Venkateswaran (2009). Safety evaluation of arachidonic acid rich Mortierella alpina biomass in albino rats-a subchronic study. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 53:186–194

Raimondi S, M Rossi, A Leonardi, MM Bianchi, T Rinaldi, A Amaretti (2014). Getting lipids from glycerol: New perspectives on biotechnological exploitation of Candida freyschussii. Microb Cell Fact 13:83–94

Rattray JBM (1984). Biotechnology and the fats and oils industry - An overview. J Amer Oil Chem Soc 61:1701–1712

Sakuradani E (2010). Advances in the production of various polyunsaturated fatty acids through oleaginous fungus Mortierella alpina breeding. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem 74:908–917

Sattayatewa C, M Arnaldos, K Pagilla (2011). Measurement of organic nitrogen and phosphorus fractions at very low concentrations in wastewater effluents. Water Environ Res 83:675–683

Singh A, OP Ward (1997). Production of high yields of arachidonic acid in a fed-batch system by Mortierella alpina ATCC 32222. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 48:1–5

Streekstra H (1997). On the safety of Mortierella alpina for the production of food ingredients, such as arachidonic acid. J Biotechnol 56:153–165

Stressler T, T Eisele, J Rost, E-M Haunschild, A Kuhn, L Fischer (2013). Production of polyunsaturated fatty acids by Mortierella alpina using submerse and solid state fermentation. Chem Ing Technol 85:318–322

Tang X, WN Chen (2014). Investigation of fatty acid accumulation in the engineered Saccharomyces cerevisiae under nitrogen limited culture condition. Bioresour Technol 162:200–206

Tang X, H Chen, T Mei, C Ge, Z Gu, H Zhang, YQ Chen, W Chen (2018). Characterization of an Omega-3 desaturase from phytophthora parasitica and application for eicosapentaenoic acid production in Mortierella alpina. Front Microbiol 9; Article 1878

Tossavainen M, U Ilyass, V Ollilainen, K Valkonen, A Ojala, M Romantschuk (2019). Influence of long term nitrogen limitation on lipid, protein and pigment production of Euglena gracilis in photoheterotrophic cultures. Peer J 7:6624–6642

Wang H, H Chen, G Hao, B Yang, Y Feng, Y Wang, L Feng, J Zhao, Y Song, H Zhang, YQ Chen, L Wang, W Chen (2013). Role of the phenylalanine-hydroxylating system in aromatic substance degradation and lipid metabolism in the oleaginous fungus Mortierella alpina. Appl Environ Microb 79:3225–3233

Wiktorowska-Owczarek A, M Berezinska, JZ Nowak (2015). PUFAs: Structures, metabolism and functions. Adv Clin Exp Med 24:931–941

Wu GX, BY Gao, ZW Zhou, XQ Lei, LD Huang, AF Li, CW Zhang (2015). Effects of high and low nitrogen concentration on the growth and lipids accumulation pattern of two oleaginous microalgae. Microbiol Chin 42:1442–1452

Yu Y, L Zhang, T Li, N Wu, L Jiang, X Ji, H Huang (2018). How nitrogen sources influence Mortierella alpina aging: From the lipid droplet proteome to the whole-cell proteome and metabolome. J Proteom 179:140–149

Zhang H, Z Wang, Y Feng, Q Cui, X Song (2019). Phytohormones as stimulators to improve arachidonic acid biosynthesis in Mortierella alpina. Enzyme Microb Technol 131:109381